Dear Steering Committee members:
Please provide your input as to PRO's & CON's of each of the versions for wording of the Vision Statement below (changes to the statements are in red). I tried to summarize Pro's & Con's that were shared in the Steering Committee meeting today. If you want to nominate other wording versions, then please post them (and consecutively number them), and provide your "PRO" rationale.
Please provide your input in the following format:
Version 1 PRO: blah blah blah
or Version 2: CON: blah blah blah
Then by this Friday, Sept. 4, the KWI team will compile the comments, send you all the summarized comments, and we will ask you each to rank order your preference for the various versions via a zoomerang survey. We will keep that survey open until Sept. 10, so that we can mail out the Membership Agreement by Sept. 11, which is close to one month before the Oct. 6 & 7 meeting. Rank ordering will hopefully avoid ties that might occur if we used gradients of agreement.
The version with the most points will be the one proposed for the Membership Agreement.
If you have questions, please e-mail Terry at tuyeki@humboldt.edu.
thx,
Terry
Vision Statement (version 1, original version)
The Klamath Basin Monitoring Program facilitates the coordination of and conducts water quality monitoring in support of the stewardship, protection, enhancement and restoration of all beneficial uses within the Klamath River watershed. The KBMP provides guidance and technical assistance in the development and implementation of water quality monitoring and research projects, resulting in the efficient collection of high quality data, as well as the sharing of credible information for assessing the health of the River basin, with the ultimate goal of restoring water quality.
PRO: By including the wording that KBMP (as a coalition) conducts water quality monitoring activities, KBMP may be a stronger "candidate" to apply (as a coalition) for grant funding, and when the monies are awarded, KBMP will still have a process by which sub-contracts for conducting the monitoring by individual members will be still be decided by the KBMP in a process that everyone will agree to.
PRO: When members understand the above vision within the context of an organizational structure that makes the awarding of such sub-contracts evident, then the wording "KBMP conducts water quality monitoring" may be more acceptable.
CON: KBMP technically does not conduct water quality monitoring; its individual member organizations do. Therefore, alternative wording is proposed to clarify this position (see Versions 2, 3 & 4)
Vision Statement (version 2)
The Klamath Basin Monitoring Program facilitates the coordination of [OMIT: and conducts] water quality monitoring by its individual members in support of the stewardship, protection, enhancement and restoration of all beneficial uses within the Klamath River watershed. The KBMP provides guidance and technical assistance in the development and implementation of water quality monitoring and research projects, resulting in the efficient collection of high quality data, as well as the sharing of credible information for assessing the health of the River basin, with the ultimate goal of restoring water quality.
PRO: KBMP technically does not conduct water quality monitoring; its individual member organizations do. Therefore, alternative wording is proposed to clarify this position.
CON: By excluding the wording that KBMP (as a coalition) conducts water quality monitoring activities, KBMP may weaken their strength to apply (as a coalition) for grant funding (i.e., they only coordinate, but do not conduct WQM). If grant monies are awarded, KBMP will still have a process and organizational structure by which sub-contracts for conducting the monitoring by individual members will be still be decided by the KBMP in a process that everyone will agree to.
CON: For years, the Coordination Group was a networking group, but still every group 'did their own thing' and could not jointly apply for grant funding.
Vision Statement (version 3)
The Klamath Basin Monitoring Program facilitates the coordination of and conducts water quality monitoring in support of the stewardship, protection, enhancement and restoration of all beneficial uses within the Klamath River watershed. (Individual members of KBMP conduct water quality monitoring in the Klamath Basin.) The KBMP provides guidance and technical assistance in the development and implementation of water quality monitoring and research projects, resulting in the efficient collection of high quality data, as well as the sharing of credible information for assessing the health of the River basin, with the ultimate goal of restoring water quality.
PRO: By inserting wording clarifying that KBMP conducts WQ monitoring vis-a-vis monitoring activities conducted by its individual members, it clarifies the disputed role of KBMP.
Vision Statement (version 4)
The Klamath Basin Monitoring Program facilitates the coordination of and conducts water quality monitoring in support of the stewardship, protection, enhancement and restoration of all beneficial uses within the Klamath River watershed. (KBMP and/or individual members of KBMP conduct water quality monitoring in the Klamath Basin.) The KBMP provides guidance and technical assistance in the development and implementation of water quality monitoring and research projects, resulting in the efficient collection of high quality data, as well as the sharing of credible information for assessing the health of the River basin, with the ultimate goal of restoring water quality.
PRO: Revises the statement added in version 3, by inserting "and/or" to include monitoring conducted by the larger coalition as well as by individual members.